(I'm still downloading the episode and won't be able to watch it for at least another hour or two. It didn't occur to me that this was a site I should avoid until after I'd watched. Oh well. I'm normally all about the spoilers, but I figured I'd wait to see it).
I am torn on this. Jessie started out as my favorite, but she really does look like a pirate when she moves. She's probably had the most extremes during the show--she had her moments that were painful, but her good performances were the most outstanding. Jodie's chin movements disturb me when she sings, and I refuse to believe she's in her 20s; I thought she was about 42. Otoh, while I know that Nancy should be younger, I find Jodie more convincing as Nancy, wrt appearance. Ultimately, I'm not sure that either of them was right for the part, though I didn't feel strongly against either of them, either. I still don't get that ALW cut Rachel, as she was the only one who seemed to be able to act and move.
I'm looking forward to seeing the Olivers' performances.