Do you think Martin changed what he was looking for in an Annie over the years. Becuase I don't believe SJP was what he originally cast with Andrea. If he was to go with a sweeter Annie from the start then why didn't he keep Kristin Vigard? So, I'm thinking that maybe he changed his view. I can Andrea and Shelley were similar and so are the 2 Allisons. So, maybe he changed then went back. With the exception of Sarah, all broadway Annies were strong belters except for Sarah she was sweet.