JKD Web Kwoon              JKD Resurrection              JKD Canada

--


  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  

JKD vs, Ninjutsu

November 22 2004 at 1:49 AM
  (Login HumbleStudent)

-
How does the way of the ninja size up to JKD.

 
 Respond to this message   
AuthorReply

(Login gv_wingchunpr)

reply

November 28 2004, 4:58 PM 

if the ninjitsu practitioner can do all thye things they show in the movies , then the ninja should win... I guess?

 
 

(Login jakep)

From what I gather.....

November 28 2004, 8:09 PM 

Ninjistu takes simple 'dirty' techiques, andd apply them in a brutal way. However, the applcation of such techniques are very technical, when compared to say, JKD.
In a real, adrennalin fueled situation, you lose many of your fine motor skills, so many Ninjitsu techniques would become obselite, wheras JKD takes the most simple and direct route to taking out an oponent.

Of course, we ALL know Nijas can fly, which kicks major ass!

 
 
Phases
(Login Phases)

Re: JKD vs, Ninjutsu

November 29 2004, 8:04 PM 

Yea, Ninjitsu artists are too technical, to many movements. So, a JKD man with a few simple techniques should beat a ninja fairly easy.

Watch out for sneak attacks, a ninja might try to drop a smoke bomb and throw ninja stars from the tree that he's hiding in. They are trained assasins, they arent very well trained to go toe to toe... they would rather throw knives at your back or pin you with poison darts from thier blow guns 20 feet away. ha!

Phases ®

 
 
Len
(Login Lenmaster)

Re: JKD vs, Ninjutsu

November 29 2004, 8:26 PM 

I've taken real ninjutsu. It's a cool art to learn but if it was something more practical or in my opinion "better" than JKD, I wouldn't still be with JKD now would I? I would say if you have a choice between Taekwondo, Karate, or Ninjutsu, take Ninjutsu. It's more practical than those arts. It also has tons of weapons so if you are a weapons buff, that is your art. I think BJJ and JKD are more practical. But for it's time, ninja were the JKD guys of their day so to speak:
Using whatever works in an emergency.

 
 
Phases
(Login Phases)

Re: JKD vs, Ninjutsu

November 29 2004, 8:53 PM 

Ive taken a few Ninja classes. The instructor was kinda creepy, like he would look at me like he knew that I knew martial arts and he was ready for my attack. haha! I had a strange sense about that guy, it was odd. I'm a very good judge of character and he seemed to be too, so it was like we were trying to figure each other out, with out speaking. Its hard to explain. haha! I would admit, his senses were strong, like, he would be good at Chi sau or intercepting, but he didnt reveal too much of HIS techniques.

Phases ®

 
 

(Login jakep)

Well......

November 30 2004, 6:33 AM 

If you just LOVE THE NINJA, take a look at realultimatepower.net the "official" ninja webpage.

The guy who made it is probably the most dangerous man alive.

 
 
Anonymous
(Login schakfu)

bujinkan

November 30 2004, 4:50 PM 

I took some classes in bujinkan ninjitsu. The major problems I had with it was the weapon focus and the stance. It is not a good art for a street fight because it assumes your opponent is using a sword or other types of weapons carried back in the day. Most of the techniques were counter attacks though, and I am not a big fan of waiting to be punched at. On the other hand its not as soft as aikido or judo because once you get an arm or a leg your striking at the armpit, neck, and face with either the side of the hand or a thub strike. Also the recent addition of the warriors creed is a nice touch.

THE WARRIOR CREED
By Robert L. Humphrey

Wherever I go,
everyone is a little bit safer because I am there.

Wherever I am,
anyone in need has a friend.

Whenever I return home,
everyone is happy I am there.

"It's a better life!"

 
 
Current Topic - JKD vs, Ninjutsu  Respond to this message   
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  
Find more forums on Martial ArtsCreate your own forum at Network54
 Copyright © 1999-2008 Network54. All rights reserved.   Terms of Use   Privacy Statement